Property insurance agents on St. Thomas

Sailboats anchored in Long Bay below the hillside homes of Charlotte Amalie

Area photo

Caribbean Risk Group

Last verified October 28, 2026

Caribbean Risk Group, LLC is an insurance agency with an office at 5060 Forts Straede, Suite 2, in Charlotte Amalie on St. Thomas.

Long Bay, Charlotte Amalie, St. Thomas. Photo: Prayitno, CC BY 2.0

Wooded Hassel Island across the turquoise water of St. Thomas Harbor, with a red boat at the waterfront below

Area photo

Guardian Insurance Company, St. Thomas

Last verified October 29, 2026

Guardian Insurance Company is a property and casualty insurer that, according to its website, was founded on St. Thomas in 1984. Its U.S.

St. Thomas Harbor, Charlotte Amalie. Photo: Smallbones, CC0

Pale yellow, red-roofed Legislature Building of the Virgin Islands on the Charlotte Amalie waterfront, seen across the harbor water

Area photo

Marshall+Sterling, St. Thomas

Last verified October 28, 2026

Marshall+Sterling is an insurance agency with offices on St. Thomas, St. Croix and St. John, and its Virgin Islands page says the firm has served the territory since it opened its first office on St.

Charlotte Amalie, St. Thomas. Photo: Андрей Бобровский, CC BY 3.0

Hull Bay on the north side of St. Thomas seen from the hills, with boats in the turquoise bay, homes on a point and an island offshore

Area photo

Shield Insurance

Last verified October 29, 2026

Shield Insurance is an insurance agency with an office at 5602 Trompeter Gade on St. Thomas, and its website says it serves clients on St. Thomas, St. John and St. Croix.

Hull Bay, St. Thomas. Photo: Gruepig, CC BY-SA 4.0